Design Critiquing Systems Jason
نویسنده
چکیده
Design critiquing systems are a type of intelligent user interface used to support human designers in decision making. This paper places design critics in the larger context of intelligent user interface approaches and surveys several critiquing systems. Each approach and system is evaluated with respect to a five-phase design improvement process. This paper concludes with a summary of the state of the art in critiquing systems and recommendations for future research directions.
منابع مشابه
COMPUTER-AIDED CRITIQUING SYSTEMS Lessons Learned and New Research Directions
A critiquing system helps designers improve their design artifacts by providing feedback. Computer-aided critiquing systems have been built in many fields and provide us with useful lessons. In this paper we analyze existing critiquing systems in terms of (1) critiquing process, (2) critiquing rules, and (3) intervention techniques. Based on this analysis, we suggest new research directions for...
متن کاملA Collaborative Development Environment for Design-Oriented Critiquing Systems
Design–oriented critiquing systems have successfully demonstrated their capability to aid users in designing artifacts. They can be seen as personal assistants helping to reflect on a particular design and to improve it. For doing so, design–oriented critiquing systems make knowledge and expertise of domain experts available to end users of authoring tools. Unfortunately, it is a quite demandin...
متن کاملSoftware architecture critics in the Argo design environment
Software architectures are high-level design representations of software systems that focus on composition of software components and how those components interact. Software architectures abstract the details of implementation and allow the designer to focus on essential design decisions. Regardless of notation, designers are faced with the task of making good design decisions that demand a bro...
متن کاملToward A Theory of Design Critiquing
............................................................................................................. 16 1. Introduction................................................................................................ 18 1.1. Definitions of Terms....................................................................................................22 1.1.1. Critiquing Methods and Condit...
متن کاملPerspective-based Critiquing: Helping Designers Cope with Conflicts among Design Intentions
Analyses of design activities indicate that conflicts detected at the solution level often originate in conflicts at the design intention level. We have extended previous computational critiquing approaches by helping designers to become aware of, understand, and resolve conflicts among design intentions. A perspective-based critiquing system allows designers to explicitly represent design inte...
متن کامل